A frequent question asked during initial consultations at Watson Law is whether there is a tangible legal advantage to winning the “race to the courthouse.” The spouse who files the initial divorce paperwork is legally designated as the “Petitioner,” while the spouse who receives the paperwork and answers is the “Respondent.” In the vast majority of Illinois Family Law cases under 750 ILCS 5/403, these labels are purely administrative and carry absolutely no weight regarding the final outcome of the case. A judge in Central Illinois, Peoria IL, or Chicago IL will not view you more favorably, give you a larger share of the assets, or award you primary custody simply because you were the one who filed the petition first.
However, while there is no inherent bias from the judge, being the Petitioner does offer a few subtle strategic and logistical advantages that Linda Watson and our attorneys often discuss with clients. Filing first gives you the power to dictate the initial timing of the legal proceedings. If you know a divorce is inevitable, filing first allows you to prepare financially, gather all necessary documents with the help of our paralegals, and secure your legal representation before the chaos begins. It also prevents you from being blindsided by a process server at your workplace, allowing you to manage the narrative across our service areas on your own terms.
Furthermore, the Petitioner has a slight structural advantage during formal court proceedings, though this only truly matters if the case goes all the way to a highly contested trial within our practice areas. The practical differences include the following in Illinois courts:
- Controlling the Venue: If you and your spouse live in different Illinois counties, filing first allows you to establish the venue in your home county (e.g., Peoria IL or Chicago IL).
- First to Present at Trial: In a formal courtroom trial, the Petitioner gets to present their opening statement first, call their witnesses first, and present their overarching narrative to the judge.
- Surprise Factor regarding Injunctions: Filing first allows you to simultaneously file emergency motions, such as temporary restraining orders to prevent the dissipation of bank accounts.